Symbolism of Psychosis According to Carl Jung:
Carl Jung approached psychosis not simply as a collapse of reality testing, but as a state in which the symbolic life of the psyche erupts with overwhelming intensity. In The Man and His Symbols, he offers a compassionate and psychologically nuanced lens that helps clinicians understand the inner logic and meaning-making within psychotic experiences. Ultimately, as therapists, our goal is to support the patient in recognizing these symbolic messages, understanding their archetypal origins, and integrating them into their conscious life, thus, transforming the psychotic experience from a pathology into a path of profound self-discovery.
Jungian Concepts:
-
Psychosis as a Waking Dream: Jung saw psychosis, especially schizophrenia, as an intrusion of the unconscious into consciousness, a "dream with open eyes" where archetypal figures and symbols manifest intensely.
-
Archetypes: Universal patterns (e.g., The Mother, The Wise Old Man) from the collective unconscious that appear as figures or themes in psychotic experiences, driving the narrative. Types of archetypes include the Shadow, the Anima, and the Animus Self.
-
Collective Unconscious: A shared, inherited layer of the psyche containing these archetypes, which psychosis taps into.
-
The Self: The central archetype of wholeness, often symbolized by mandalas (circles, squares, geometric patterns), representing the goal of integration. The archetype of wholeness; in psychosis, its emergence often involves a symbolic "death" of the old self and a "rebirth" into a new, integrated state.
-
Transformation: The aim of Jungian analysis, where these symbols help move the psyche from fragmentation to integration, in an attempt to achieve a deeper, more complete sense of self.
-
Synchronicity: Meaningful coincidences within the psychotic experience that offer symbolic clues to the individual's inner state and path.
-
Symbols vs. Signs: Signs point to something known (a stop sign), while symbols represent something unknown or inexpressible, conveying deeper psychic truths.
Jungian Conceptualization of Psychosis:
The Psyche Speaks in Symbols, Especially When Overwhelmed:
Jung believed that symbols are the natural language of the unconscious mind. In everyday life, these symbols express themselves in dreams, fantasies, slips of the tongue, and creative work.
Example: During psychosis, this symbolic material may emerge in an unfiltered way, overtaking the person’s ordinary sense of meaning and connection to reality.
Clinically: This perspective frames psychotic content as meaningful communication from the psyche that has become too powerful, intense, or unregulated for the person to manage.
Psychosis as a Flood of Archetypal Imagery:
Jung observed that psychotic content often includes grandiose, catastrophic, mythic, or cosmic themes. He described this as the "activation of the collective unconscious", particularly archetypes, which are universal templates of human experience.
Example: Themes of rebirth or destruction, battles between good and evil, divine or persecutory forces, and symbols of wholeness such as circles, mandalas, or radiant light.
Clinically: This helps clinicians meet psychotic material with curiosity rather than fear, recognizing that the mind may be drawing on universal human motifs to express overwhelming emotion, trauma, or developmental strain.
When Symbolism Loses Its Flexibility, It Becomes Literal:
Healthy symbolic functioning allows the psyche to use metaphor and imagination without losing contact with consensual reality. In psychosis, symbolic imagery may become literalized and experienced as objectively real instead of metaphorical.
Example: A symbolic sense of being watched becomes a conviction that actual agents are surveilling. A symbolic intuition of inner transformation can lead to the belief that one is a divine or messianic figure.
Clinically: Shifts from symbolic meaning to concrete meaning are central to the formation of delusions and hallucinations. It invites gentle inquiry into the symbolic story that is being lived out as a literal fact.
Psychosis Can Reflect a Psyche Struggling Toward Integration:
Jung did not romanticize psychosis, yet he noted that unconscious eruptions often express a psychological attempt toward balance. When the ego is too fragile, the psyche may try to reorganize itself through intense symbolic narratives, even if the process becomes disorienting or dangerous.
Clinically:
Modern trauma-informed approaches resonate with this idea. Psychosis may represent the mind’s effort to reorganize overwhelming experiences or emotional states.
Prioritizing Containment, Not Confrontation:
Jung emphasized that symbolic material arising in psychosis should be approached gently, respectfully, and with carefully maintained boundaries. Direct interpretation or confrontation can destabilize the person.
Clinically: This perspective supports validating emotional and symbolic content without endorsing literal conclusions. It encourages clinicians to maintain empathy for the symbolic narrative while also safeguarding grounding and safety.
Symbolic Understanding Supports Recovery and Reconnection:
Jung believed that, once the acute phase of psychosis recedes, elements of the symbolic material can become part of the person’s self-understanding and resilience if they are explored thoughtfully.
Clinically: This highlights the importance of meaning-making, narrative integration, and gentle exploration of themes that emerged during psychosis. It also supports helping the individual reclaim a sense of coherence and agency.
Object Relations Theory of Psychosis (revised by Michael Garrett)
Michael Garrett uses object relations theory to understand psychosis as a response to overwhelming internal experiences rather than only a biological malfunction. In this model, psychosis occurs when the mind can no longer integrate thoughts, emotions, and self-states in an organized way. A person may revert to earlier, more fragile modes of coping that were shaped in childhood and that can no longer contain the intensity of current stress.
Psychosis as a Return to Early Ways of Coping:
When a person is overwhelmed, the mind may fall back on early coping strategies that rely heavily on fear, emotional extremes, and concrete thinking. Symbolic and reflective thinking becomes difficult, which can lead to delusions or hallucinations that feel literal and immediate.
Example: A client who feels abandoned by loved ones may not be able to tolerate the emotional pain. Instead of experiencing sadness or anger directly, the person may believe that neighbors are plotting against them. The external threat reflects an internal feeling of danger and vulnerability.
Clinically: Clinicians should explore the emotional context surrounding the onset of symptoms. Understanding the psychological stressors helps shift the frame from “this is irrational” to “this is an overwhelmed mind trying to cope.” This approach reduces shame and increases engagement in therapy.
Internal Relational Experiences Become Externalized:
We all develop internal images of caregivers and important figures. In psychosis, these internal figures may feel threatening or punishing and can be projected outward. Experiences like voices or persecutory beliefs can reflect internal relational patterns rather than literal external dangers.
Example: A voice that repeatedly calls someone “worthless” often echoes the tone of a critical or rejecting caregiver from childhood. The person experiences this internalized figure as if it were an external entity.
Clinically: Instead of confronting the literal content of the delusion or voice, the therapist can gently explore relational themes. This helps the client understand the emotional meaning behind symptoms and fosters insight into how early experiences shape current distress.
Symptoms as Attempts to Stay Emotionally Intact:
Garrett highlights that psychotic symptoms often function as a survival strategy. Delusions may provide structure, and voices may give form to feelings that are too painful to hold consciously. Symptoms become a way to manage emotional overwhelm.
Example: A client who feels deep shame may believe that a powerful organization is monitoring them. Although frightening, the delusion creates a sense of order and explains their internal discomfort in a concrete way.
Clinically: Therapists can validate the protective function of symptoms rather than invalidate the experience. This approach reduces defensiveness and builds trust, opening the door to exploring healthier ways to manage overwhelming emotions.
Blurring of Self and Other:
One hallmark of psychosis is difficulty distinguishing internal thoughts from external reality. This blurring can lead to experiences such as thought broadcasting or the belief that another person is controlling one’s actions.
Example: A person who feels intensely self-critical may believe that coworkers can hear their thoughts and are judging them. What is actually self-directed criticism becomes interpreted as external scrutiny.
Clinically: Clinicians can help clients rebuild boundaries between internal and external experience. Techniques that enhance grounding, emotional awareness, and mentalization can help strengthen the ability to reflect on thoughts rather than experience them as literal events.
The Role of Trauma, Shame, and Early Attachment:
Early attachment disruptions or chronic shame can weaken the development of a stable sense of self. Later stress may exceed the capacity of these fragile internal structures, making the person more vulnerable to psychotic experiences.
Example: A client who grew up with inconsistent caregiving may have learned that the world is unpredictable and unsafe. When faced with adult stress, the person may develop paranoid delusions that others are watching or judging them. The delusion mirrors early life experiences of insecurity.
Clinically: Treatment benefits from a trauma-informed, compassionate stance. Clinicians should assess for early relational trauma and shame and understand how these experiences shape the client’s sense of self. This helps create more targeted and effective interventions.
Therapeutic Work as a Process of Safety and Integration:
From an object relations perspective, healing requires a stable and genuine therapeutic relationship. The therapist becomes a reliable presence who helps the client reconnect with parts of themselves that were split off or disowned.
Example: A client who hears a harsh, punishing voice may gradually learn to link that voice to early experiences with a critical parent. Through therapy, the client starts to recognize that this internal figure is not an external threat and begins to integrate this part of themselves with more self-compassion.
Clinically: Therapists should prioritize the creation of a steady, calm, and trustworthy relationship. This relationship becomes a corrective emotional experience that helps the client rebuild reflective thinking, reduce fear of internal experiences, and strengthen their sense of self.
Sources:
Jung, C. G. (1997). Man & His Symbols. Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group.